Jury Selection Process, Sequestration, Verdict and Relevant Controversies:
OJ Simpson's case had already set the record for being the longest jury trial in the history of California even before the commencement of closing arguments. For a better part of the year, the jury in the case had been sequestered and was displaying signs of exhaustion and strain (Linder, 2000). Actually, Judge Ito was blamed for permitting the trial to drag on as he appeared unable to keep lawyers under control. The sequestration of the jury was also evident in the fact that they only took three hours to deliberate on the case that generated 150 witnesses in a period of more than 133 days and cost more than $20 million to conduct.
In this criminal trial, one of the key messages from the defense was that the Los Angeles Police Department was mainly geared towards bringing down a famous African-American. This message was specifically targeted at the jury, many of whom had negative experiences with the LAPD. The trial team not only maintained but also used a jury consultant effectively to carry out pretrial jury research and periodic analysis during the trial to understand the possible reactions of the jurors to significant thematic messages and evidence introduced during the trial. Therefore, jury research is carried out to determine the various kinds of juror reactions to the case messages or themes.
The jury in OJ Simpson's trial comprised of 9 Blacks, 1 Hispanic, 2 Whites with 10 women and 10 men whose educational level included 2 college graduates, 9 high school graduates, and 1 without diploma. The racial composition of this jury was mainly influenced by the prosecution's decision to file the case in downtown Los Angeles instead of Santa Monica, the judicial district where the offense took place as is usually the case. Poll results indicated that many whites believed Simpson was guilty while many blacks believed he was not guilty. Consequently, the decision to file the case in Santa Monica could have been the huge mistake the prosecution could have made.
The jury selection process for this case started on September 24, 1994 with around...
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now